SpoilerTV Readers’ Poll: The 2025 Show of the Year Results Are In

Every year, SpoilerTV readers show up in force to celebrate the series that mattered most to them — not just the biggest hits, but the shows that inspired loyalty, passion, and community. The 2025 Show of the Year poll was no exception, drawing thousands of votes and some deeply emotional responses, particularly in a year marked by high-profile cancellations. This year’s results tell a clear story: fan connection still matters, longevity still counts, and cancellations don’t erase impact. Here are your Top 3 Shows of 2025, as voted by SpoilerTV readers. #1 NCIS: Tony & Ziva It’s hard to overstate just how dominant NCIS: Tony & Ziva was in this poll. The long-awaited reunion of two of the most beloved characters in the NCIS universe didn’t just meet expectations, it exceeded them. The series balanced nostalgia with emotional maturity, exploring how Tony and Ziva had changed, what they’d lost, and what they were still fighting for. Fans praised the show for its character-driven storytelling, grounded emotional arcs, and the palpable chemistry that never faded. That’s what made the recent Paramount+ cancellation announcement so devastating. After building a massive and passionate fanbase in a short time, the decision to end the series left viewers shocked, frustrated, and vocal in their disappointment. Social media lit up with calls for reconsideration, renewals, or a new home for the show. For SpoilerTV readers, however, the message is clear: Cancelled or not, NCIS: Tony & Ziva defined 2025. #2 Law & Order: SVU More than two decades in, Law & Order: SVU continues to prove why it’s one of television’s most enduring dramas. In 2025, the series once again delivered emotionally charged cases, strong performances, and storylines that resonated deeply with its audience. Readers cited the show’s consistency, its willingness to tackle difficult subject matter, and its evolving character dynamics as reasons it remains appointment television. What’s remarkable isn’t just that SVU finished second, it’s that it’s still competing at the very top against newer, buzzy series. That kind of staying power doesn’t happen by accident. It happens because of trust built over years, and a fanbase that continues to show up. For many voters, SVU isn’t just a show, it’s a television constant. #3 Rescue: HI-Surf Few results sparked as much emotion as Rescue: HI-Surf landing in third place. The FOX series quickly built a devoted following thanks to its high-stakes rescues, strong ensemble cast, and immersive setting. Viewers connected with both the adrenaline-fueled action and the personal stories woven into each episode. For many fans, it felt like a rare broadcast drama that understood how to balance spectacle with heart. That’s why FOX’s decision to cancel the show after just one season hit particularly hard. Despite growing buzz and a passionate fandom, the series didn’t get the chance many felt it deserved. Finishing third in the SpoilerTV poll is a testament to how deeply the show resonated, and how loudly fans are still mourning its loss. This year’s poll results reflect a recurring theme in modern television: fan passion doesn’t always align with network decisions. Two of the top three shows were cancelled, yet both inspired enough loyalty to outperform dozens of competitors. That speaks volumes about their impact and about the SpoilerTV readership itself. Whether it was the emotional payoff of NCIS: Tony & Ziva, the enduring strength of Law & Order: SVU, or the short-lived but powerful connection forged by Rescue: HI-Surf, one thing is certain: These shows mattered. And in 2025, that’s what counted most.