Cardinals’ perfect trade offer for Cubs’ Seiya Suzuki

There are plenty of rumors that the St. Louis Cardinals could chase in trade talks. And one guy should be on the market, an insider said. Therefore, here is the Cardinals’ perfect trade offer to the Cubs for Seiya Suzuki.

The Cardinals aren’t too far ahead of the Cubs. Heading into Thursday’s slate of games, they stood at 37-28 with a 4.5-game gap between them and the Cubs.

However, the Cardinals are trending up while the Cubs have lost their early season momentum. The Cubs peaked at 27-12, but have lost 22 of their last 29 games in a horrible stretch.

Why do the Cardinals need OF Seiya Suzuki?

The Cardinals rank No. 12 in baseball in terms of batting average. But their power lags a bit, standing at No. 16 with 73 home runs. Perhaps the biggest question is how much Suzuki can provide for their offense?

Yes, Suzuki hit 32 homers and drove in 103 runs in 2025. But in his age-32 season, Suzuki hasn’t been quite as effective. With the season closing in on the halfway mark, Suzuki has just nine homers and a meager 22 RBIs in 225 at-bats.

But how much of that is the Cubs’ offense? Or is it Suzuki’s dwindling skills? It’s a fair question to ask.

One thing seems certain, according to The Athletic. The Cubs and Suzuki likely don’t have a long-term relationship.

“Suzuki, who turns 32 in August, is not likely to be part of the team’s future,” Ken Rosenthal wrote. “So, it would behoove the Cubs to explore the market for him. Perhaps Suzuki could bring back a starting pitcher who also is a potential free agent, helping the club fill a more dire need.”

What would the Cardinals’ perfect offer be?

This is where things get very interesting. The Cardinals have an emerging star in outfielder Jordan Walker. And Alec Burleson is having a fine season so far. Ivan Herrera has been a pleasant surprise, along with JJ Wetherholt.

But of that group, only Walker qualifies as a star. So adding a bat like Suzuki — if you get anything close to the 2025 version — is a need. That is, if the Cardinals see themselves as a legitimate playoff threat. And at this point in the season, few teams will look at their own seasons and have full-on concession-speech takes.

Trading for Suzuki requires precision. The Cardinals can’t give up much for a guy who could be on the edge of leaving the prime of his career.

A younger outfielder is probably the starting point. Their thought might go to 17-year-old Emanuel Luna, but his upside, though potentially five years removed from a big-league evaluation, seems to be a drawback for letting him go.

That brings us to Tai Peete. He’s 20 years old and has enough upside to tempt the Cubs. He is considered a 2028 arrival, according to MLB.com.

“He’s built like a wide receiver with a slender 6-foot-2 frame and packs a punch as well with plus raw power,” MLB.com wrote. “He retains his plus arm strength from his pitching days. And after beginning his career on the dirt, he moved to center field in 2025 to strong reviews because his plus speed helps him gallop gap to gap to chase down balls.

“But so much comes down to Peete’s ability to make contact. Opposing pitchers have eaten him alive with non-fastballs. His left-handed swing can look pretty, but he’ll yank over the top of inside breakers and swing over changeups on the outer half with little hope for contact.”

For this deal to work, the Cubs have to believe Peete can eventually recognize offspeed deliveries earlier out of the pitcher’s hand.

“(Peete) did a better job of lifting and pulling when he did put bat on ball last year,” MLB.com wrote. “It isn’t a hit tool that can be fixed overnight, but in its talent acquisition and development phase, St. Louis can take its time getting Peete to hit just enough for an everyday role.”

And that would transfer to the Cubs’ organization.

The Cardinals would likely have to throw a pitcher into the deal. Braden Davis, a left-hander, might be that guy. He has potential, but also question marks, according to MLB.com.

“There was a ton of ride and run on the (fastball) that lower-level hitters just couldn’t handle,” MLB.com wrote. “But its below-average velo also comes with below-average extension, and it’s likely that more experienced bats will read it better.”

However, the changeup brings hope.

“Davis’ best pitch is a killer 80-82 mph changeup that had a 61 percent whiff rate across both levels,” MLB.com wrote. “It moves much like the heater and has only a smidge less spin, but the velo differential fooled batters and led to dominance against righties. A low-80s slider also showed some depth as an option moving gloveside, and a mid-80s cutter bridged the repertoire.”

The post Cardinals’ perfect trade offer for Cubs’ Seiya Suzuki appeared first on ClutchPoints.